Making ice cream in your home can be a lot cheaper and better than buying outside, plus you can whip it up anyway you like. Yes, you want one of those adding splendor in your kitchen, but they can cry up a loud sound. That’s why we’ve assembled the quietest ice cream makers. We’ve reviewed and compared the top rated choices to come out with the best quiet ones that will make delicious treats without turning you bitter with its loud humming noise.
In a hurry? The quietest ice cream makers on the market in 2024 are the Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker and Cuisinart 1.5 Quart Frozen Yoghurt ICE-21P1. We love the Nostalgia for its low noise level and its capability to make up to 4 quarts in minutes. The Cuisinart’s noise level is not as low as the Nostalgia, but it has pretty impressive and long-lasting features.
You may also want to check out the Best Quiet Blender in 2024.
Quiet Ice Cream Maker: Quick Comparison
TOP RATED  |
Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker
| Check Price |
RUNNER UP  |
Cuisinart 1.5 Quart Frozen Yoghurt ICE-21P1
| Check Price |
BEST VALUE  |
Whynter ICM-201SB
| Check Price |
PREMIUM ICE CREAM MACHINE  |
Lello 4080 Musso Lussino Ice Cream Machine
| Check Price |
WITH COMPRESSOR  |
Cuisinart ICE-100
| Check Price |
Quietest Ice Cream Maker 2024: Reviews
1. Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker
Best Rated
This ice cream maker is able to capably make up to 4 quarts of ice cream, gelato, and frozen yogurt in one mixing process.
The large capacity means that you can spend less time making frozen treats and more time actually enjoying them with your family.
Cleaning up after each usage is easy and saves time since the container is made with a plastic that you can easily wipe off.
It also comes with a powerful motor that can independently churn the ingredients, therefore requiring zero effort from you in terms of stirring or manually mixing it.
The motor lock is a safety feature that is built in to keep the motor in place, in order for all the parts of the unit to be highly secure.
As for making your ice cream, you can either follow the recipe provided or make up your own. The lid and lid cap is used for storing left-over ice cream in the freezer.
While it definitely makes noise as the motor runs in order to carefully mix your delicious treats, it is not as loud as a blender or a food processor, and this is actually one of the quietest ice cream makers currently out there.
Pros
- It features an ergonomically designed carry handle that makes transport easy
- Clean-up is easy
- Large capacity ice cream or gelato maker
- Affordable quality ice cream maker
- Powerful and durable motor
Cons
- You have to add ice and salt
2. Cuisinart 1.5 Quart Frozen Yogurt ICE-21P1
Runner Up
If you want to make your ice cream and frozen creamy treats in record time, then the Cuisinart 1.5 offers you a fast option with a mixing time that is just over 20 minutes.
The transparent lid is easy to lock and it comes with a large spout that makes adding ingredients easy and mess free.
The bowl is doubly insulated thereby eliminating the need to add ice. The maximum capacity for every round is 1.5 quarts of frozen desserts and freezing the bowl can take as much as 16 to 24 hours.
It is fully automatic, requiring no other effort from you other than adding the ingredients and pushing a button, that is if you don’t add scooping out the ice cream, cleaning up the ice cream maker after use, wow, don’t we wish they were self-cleaning.
The heavy-duty motor is strong enough to handle ice cream, frozen yogurt, sherbet, sorbet and frozen drinks. The cooling liquid is inside a double insulated wall, allowing it to cool faster and evenly.
Pros
- 3-year limited warranty
- Elegant design and appearance
- Non-slip rubber feet keep it stationary during use
Cons
- The noise level is not low enough
3. Whynter ICM-201SB
Best Value
This is a self-contained dessert maker that does not require pre-freezing to make ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sorbet.
The stainless steel housing contains a reliable built-in audible timer.
It has a large capacity 2.1 quart mixing bowl.
The stainless steel is BPA-free and can be removed for easy cleaning and storage.
It includes a safety motor protection function that automatically shuts it off when the mixture is frozen solid. Another great feature is that you can fully customize your recipes.
It is incredibly easy to master and use and can cool down from -0.4 to -31oF.
Pros
- Small footprint
- No pre-freezing required
- It includes a powerful compressor freezer
Cons
- This is louder than the others due to having a more powerful motor
4. Lello 4080 Musso Lussino Ice Cream Machine
Best Premium Quiet Ice Cream Maker
This is the costliest unit on this list but that’s because it is a professional-grade frozen ice cream maker.
The mixing is supremely consistent and it comes with a timer control operation for different frozen confections.
This ice cream maker is fully automatic, all you need to do is to pour in the ingredients, push two buttons, and have the best whipped frozen dessert in no time at all, okay actually in 30 minutes later.
Another convenient advantage is that you can start making another batch immediately after you’re done with the last one because the bowl doesn’t require to be frozen for hours in a freezer.
Pros
- It makes the smoothest and best-flavored ice cream
- You can make as many batches faster
- The noise level is around 40dB
Cons
- It is quite pricey
5. Cuisinart ICE-100
Best Ice Cream Maker With A Compressor
If you’re on the look-out for a fully automatic ice cream maker that is incorporated with a commercial grade compressor, you certainly wouldn’t go wrong with the Cuisinart ICE-100.
It has a 10-minute keep cool feature that can keep your ice cream and gelato cool after it has automatically shut-down.
You can make up to 1.5 quart capacity every time and the timer can be set between 10 minutes to 60 minutes. It has an anodized aluminum mixing bowl with a carry-handle that doesn’t need to be pre-chilled or frozen before use.
It comes with two unique paddles that mix and aerate the ingredients in the mixing bowl to create your frozen dessert.
The gelato and sorbet paddle perfectly incorporate air in the ingredients and create richly textured results with intense flavor. The ice cream paddle is included to perfectly churn for smooth, creamy results.
Pros
- Touchpad control panel
- LCD readout
- Cools desserts faster
- Long-lasting materials
Cons
- A bit louder than the others
Best Quiet Ice Cream Machine Buying Guide
Freezing method
Traditional Ice Cream Makers
These are the most traditional and physically demanding of all types of ice cream makers. These machines are made with an inner metal container surrounded by ice and rock salt in an outer bucket. They are also the cheaper of the other two kinds.
Pre-Frozen
If you’re going to be making ice cream at least once or twice a week, then going with a machine that has a canister you can freeze is an affordable option.
The drawbacks of these kinds are that they do require some planning ahead, as the canister, which is filled with liquid coolant, needs to be placed in a freezer for up to 24 hours before use.
Self-Refrigerating
As the name suggests, these are the ones that can generate the cold needed to freeze your deserts without making use of a freezer. They generally require more than pouring in your ingredients, pushing a button or switch, and waiting for 20 to 40 minutes in most cases. They are the costliest types though.
Price
Each ice cream maker has its features that determine its prices. While bucket-types are cheaper, you might want to reconsider the amount of work that goes into using those types, especially if you’re planning to make ice cream regularly.
Final Thoughts About Top Quietest Ice Cream Maker Machines On The Market
We’ve compiled the best quiet ones available in 2024 that we’ve reviewed and compared to figure out the ones that achieve the best results.
The top two quietest ice cream makers are the Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker and Cuisinart 1.5 Quart Frozen Yoghurt ICE-21P1.
Your choice should be influenced by how frequently you want to make ice cream, the size of your freezer and the crowd you’re planning to feed, which is why we’ve provided you with a versatile list.
Dave Pearson is a Canadian musician, sound editor, and audiophile. He is also the founder and owner of the website SoundProofGeek. On SoundProofGeek, Pearson offers advice and resources on audio equipment, including how to assess and improve audio quality, how to troubleshoot and repair audio equipment, and how to improve the music listening experience.
Table of Contents