Kilmat and Noico are some of the top choices when it comes to sound deadening mats for your car. But what are the differences between these two products and which one is better for your needs?
Read on to find out who won the Kilmat vs Noico battle and how they compare in terms of effectiveness, thickness, dimensions, preparation, ease of installation, materials they are made of, and price.
We recommend you read the best car sound deadening materials 2024 article as well.
Kilmat vs Noico: Quick Comparison
WINNER  |
Kilmat
| Check Price |
  |
Noico
| Check Price |
Kilmat vs Noico: Differences and Similarities
Effectiveness
When considering the best sound deadening mat to purchase, its effectiveness is the most important factor to consider. This is because you need something to work properly and for a long time.
Both materials are made using butyl rubber and so their effectiveness based on the material would be the same. Butyl rubber gives the product good sound deadening properties, and also heat resistance.
Kilmat is made completely of butyl rubber and so it’s very effective in helping you keep the noise out of your car, thereby improving the internal acoustics. It also reflects the engine heat due to its good heat resistant properties. It’s odorless and gives you comfort while you make use of it.
Noico is also made of butyl rubber but unlike Kilmat, it has an asphalt underlay which emits unpleasant odor in higher temperatures. Asphalt mats are good sound deadeners, but not as good as butyl and so you can expect that the effectiveness of Noico would be less than that of Kilmat.
Also, asphalt-based products do not have good heat resistance, so when it comes to all-round effectiveness, Kilmat is the best choice for you.
Thickness
The greater the thickness of a mat, the better it is at absorbing the noise trying to get into your car. Both Kilamt and Noico measure 0.08” thickness and are therefore equal in this aspect.
Note that thickness is not the only criteria with which you choose the best sound deadening product. Even if both products have the same thickness, it doesn’t mean they perform the same.
Kilmat blocks out more road, traffic and other unwanted noise with the same thickness.
Dimensions
It’s necessary to ensure the size of the product you are buying would adequately cover up your car without having lots of leftovers. Dimensions by themselves do not affect the effectiveness of a product but using a large enough size allows you to properly cover your car and keep the noise out.
Kilmat measures 15.7” x 9.8” x 0.08”, while Noico measures 29.5” x 19.5” x 0.08”. They have the same thickness but are not of the same size as Noico is bigger.
So your choice of one mat over the other based on size depends on the size of your car. If you require large sheets to properly cover the interior of your car, then Noico is the mat for you.
Preparation
The preparation for the installation of sound deadener mats is pretty much the same. It’s easy and straightforward and all you have to do is ensure the surface is clean. A clean surface allows for better adhesion and smooth finish.
You will also need tools to cut up the mats into the desired shapes and sizes and as both mats are made to be user friendly, you can handle it by yourself.
Ease of Installation
The ease of preparation for both mats transcends unto the installation. And so even if you are new at it, you can do a neat job by yourself.
You may only need to have a professional install it for you if you do not have the time or just don’t want to do it yourself.
Both mats have an indicator that guides you to install them properly, so you just can’t get it wrong.
The mats come in sizes that can easily be cut up to fit different areas of your car that you wish to soundproof. You then use a roller to make it smooth.
So in terms of ease of installation, neither is better than the other as both mats are very easy to install.
Materials They Are Made Of
Butyl rubber is known for its effective heat resistance and sound deadening properties, and it’s the material that is used in both mats. That’s why they are good at absorbing the outside noise to allow you to enjoy your car stereo better.
While Kilmat is made purely of butyl rubber, Noico has an asphalt underlay. Asphalt is another material that’s used in the construction of sound deadening mats although it’s not as effective as butyl.
So its use in Noico reduces the sound deading property, and also reduces its heat resistance.
Asphalt produces an unpleasant smell when exposed to high temperature and that is a turn off for quite a few people. So in terms of materials used, Kilmat has the upper hand as its material is more reliable and effective.
Price
The price difference between both products isn’t much, but it exists nonetheless. Noico costs a bit more than KIlmat of the same thickness. So if you are a shopper on a tight budget, your best option among the two would be Kilmat.
Kilmat Review
Kilmat is a self-adhesive sound deadening mat that’s made of butyl rubber.
It weighs 0.5 lbs/ft2 and is relatively cheap.
With this soundproofing product, you don’t have to worry about installation difficulty as it’s user friendly and has an indicator to aid you.
You get more than just a good price from Kilmat, you also get great effectiveness as it will keep both the noise and heat out.
With dimensions of 15.7” x 9.8” x 0.08”, you can be sure that the sheets are large enough to cover up every part of your car. Thickness is a factor that contributes to a mat’s performance and at 0.08”, you just need to relax and enjoy your drive.
Even in the heat, it’s odorless and you will remain comfortable.
Pros
- Great sound-canceling the product
- Heat resistant
- Great price
- Made of butyl rubber
- Self-adhesive mat
- Easy to install
- Odorless
Cons
- Package doesn’t come with a roller
Noico Review
Noico sound deadening mat comes in a thickness of either 0.05” or 0.08”.
As thickness is an important factor when it comes to the effectiveness of a soundproofing mat, the obvious choice for you if you want a better quality of soundproofing would be the 0.08” thick Noico mat.
Even though it‘s adequately thick, it’s made to be a lightweight product at 0.7 lbs/ft2 so that its installation in all parts of your car won’t have an effect on the overall weight of your car.
The density is still optimum even at that weight to ensure you get good results when you use it.
Installation is very easy and you do not need any special skills to get this done.
Noico mat is made with butyl rubber and asphalt. The addition of asphalt reduces the sound-absorbing and heat resistance properties of the mat slightly.
Unlike with Kilmat, this product has the smell of rubber and should only be used if you can tolerate the smell, or if you stay in an area of cold weather.
Pros
- User friendly and easy to install
- Affordable
- Adequately thick
- Self-adhesive mat
Cons
- Has a rubber smell
Conclusion
Kilmat vs Noico: and the winner is …
This review is to provide you with adequate information about both products so that you can make informed choices on which is best for you and your car.
Kilmat is the best choice for you if you want maximum effectiveness, are on a tight budget, and you can’t stand the smell of rubber. While Noico is the best choice for you if you need more flexibility with the sizes as they provide you with more options.
Both products are similar in overall performance, so your choice of one over the other would be largely based on personal preference. But be rest assured that you will get good value for your money no matter the mat you choose.
Dave Pearson is a Canadian musician, sound editor, and audiophile. He is also the founder and owner of the website SoundProofGeek. On SoundProofGeek, Pearson offers advice and resources on audio equipment, including how to assess and improve audio quality, how to troubleshoot and repair audio equipment, and how to improve the music listening experience.
Table of Contents
Comments are closed.